Double materiality is the principle of the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) that a sustainability matter must be reported if it is material from an impact perspective (the company's effects on people and the environment), from a financial perspective (sustainability-related effects on the company's financial position, performance, cash flows, access to finance or cost of capital), or both. A double materiality assessment (DMA) is the structured process through which a company identifies its impacts, risks and opportunities (IROs), assesses them from both perspectives and decides which ESRS topics and disclosures it has to report.
In short: A CSRD double materiality assessment runs in seven steps: (1) set up the project, governance and scoring methodology, (2) understand your business context and value chain, (3) identify and engage affected stakeholders, (4) identify impacts, risks and opportunities (top-down or bottom-up), (5) assess impact materiality on severity and likelihood, (6) assess financial materiality and apply your own thresholds, (7) consolidate, validate and document the result and map material topics to ESRS datapoints. Under the revised ESRS (mandatory from FY2027) the process is more proportionate: no exhaustive IRO search, sector data for the value chain, and updates only when something significant changes.
This guide explains what a double materiality assessment is and how to do it, from kick-off to the audited sustainability statement. Two companion articles go deeper: if you already know the basics and want to know what the 2026 standards changed, read the double materiality assessment under the revised ESRS. If you want to see every step applied to a real-looking company with scores and thresholds, read our double materiality assessment example. If you first want to know which type of materiality assessment you need (single or double, mandatory or voluntary), start with our overview of the materiality assessment.
What is double materiality?
Double materiality combines two views of the same sustainability matter. A matter is material if it meets at least one of them:
| Impact materiality ("inside-out") | Financial materiality ("outside-in") | |
|---|---|---|
| Core question | How does the company affect people and the environment? | How do sustainability matters affect the company's finances? |
| What you assess | Actual and potential, negative and positive impacts | Risks and opportunities |
| Criteria | Severity (scale, scope, irremediable character) and, for potential impacts, likelihood | Likelihood and potential magnitude of financial effects |
| Value chain | Own operations, upstream and downstream | Own operations, upstream and downstream |
| Typical example | Greenhouse gas emissions from purchased steel | Rising carbon costs that squeeze margins |
The two perspectives are connected. A severe impact today often becomes a financial risk tomorrow, through regulation, litigation, customer pressure or the loss of a licence to operate. That is why the CSRD asks for both instead of choosing one.
Single vs. double materiality. The ISSB standards (IFRS S1 and S2) use financial materiality only, while GRI focuses on impact materiality. The ESRS combine both. We compare the approaches in ISSB vs. ESRS materiality assessment and GRI vs. ESRS materiality assessment.
The unit of analysis is the IRO: an impact, a risk or an opportunity, each described as specifically as possible and linked to a value chain stage and a time horizon (short term equals the reporting period of the financial statements, medium term up to five years, long term more than five years). Our explainer on impacts, risks and opportunities under the CSRD covers the definitions in detail.
Who must carry out a double materiality assessment after Omnibus I?
The Omnibus I Directive (EU) 2026/470 narrowed the CSRD scope sharply. Today, the DMA is mandatory for:
| Company type | First ESRS report | DMA |
|---|---|---|
| EU companies with more than 1,000 employees and more than €450 million net turnover that already reported (wave one) | Already reporting | Mandatory |
| Former wave-two companies above the new thresholds | FY2027 | Mandatory |
| Non-EU groups with more than €450 million EU turnover and an EU subsidiary or branch with more than €200 million turnover | FY2028 | Mandatory |
| Companies below the thresholds, incl. listed SMEs | No obligation | Voluntary |
Wave-one companies that now fall below the thresholds may be exempted by their Member State for financial years 2025 and 2026, so check how your country transposes the directive.
Which version of the ESRS applies? The revised ESRS (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563) are mandatory for financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027. For FY2026, companies can choose between the 2023 ESRS, the revised ESRS in full, or the 2023 ESRS with specific reliefs, including the top-down DMA approach. You have to state your choice in the sustainability statement.
Out of scope? Companies with up to 1,000 employees can report under the Voluntary Standard (VS), the successor to the VSME, which requires no materiality assessment. A voluntary DMA can still pay off, for example if you expect to grow into scope, supply large CSRD reporters or report under GRI. See VSME vs. ESRS: which standard applies after Omnibus.
What the ESRS require: the official requirements at a glance
Searching for "official guidance" on the CSRD double materiality requirement leads to several documents with different legal weight. This is how they fit together:
| Source | Legal status | What it governs |
|---|---|---|
| ESRS 1 (revised), chapter on double materiality | Binding (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563) | The method: top-down and bottom-up approaches (§27, §28), reasonable and supportable information without undue cost or effort (§32), value chain (§33), updates (§34), severity precedence for human rights (§40), stakeholder engagement (§42), gross vs. net (§43), positive impacts (§44), financial materiality (§50) |
| ESRS 2 IRO-1 | Binding | Concise description of the DMA process, significant changes to it and when it was last updated |
| ESRS 2 IRO-2 | Binding | Description of the material IROs; if climate change is not material, the basis for that conclusion (§37(b)) |
| ESRS 2 SBM-3 | Binding | How material IROs interact with strategy, business model and financial effects |
| Limited assurance | Binding under the CSRD | The auditor reviews the sustainability statement, including the DMA process |
| EFRAG IG 1 | Non-binding guidance | Written for the 2023 ESRS; still useful background, but the revised ESRS 1 text prevails where they differ |
Three things the ESRS deliberately do not prescribe: scoring scales, numerical thresholds and a materiality matrix. You define the methodology yourself and justify it. In return, the revised ESRS 1 states that you "shall not disclose" information that is not material (§24), which makes a clean DMA the filter for your entire report. For the full background on each paragraph, see what the revised ESRS changed for the DMA; the official texts are on EUR-Lex and in the Commission's adoption announcement.
How to conduct a double materiality assessment in 7 steps
The following process reflects the revised ESRS 1 and lessons from the first CSRD reporting cycles. Steps 2 to 4 often overlap; what matters is that each step leaves a documented output.
Step 1: Set up the project, governance and methodology
A DMA is a cross-functional project, not a sustainability-team side task.
- Team: a project lead from sustainability, plus finance or controlling, risk management, legal and compliance, HR and procurement. A sponsor on the management board makes sure the result is owned at the top.
- Scope: which group entities, business units and value chain stages are covered, and whether you report under the 2023 or the revised ESRS for FY2026.
- Methodology: define scoring scales, the gross vs. net rule, how IROs are aggregated to topics and your materiality thresholds before anyone scores anything, and have the methodology approved. Auditors want to see that thresholds were not tuned after the results were known.
- Tooling: decide between spreadsheets and dedicated double materiality assessment software, and whether you need external support. Our comparison of DMA software vs. consultants helps with that decision.
Step 2: Understand the business context and value chain
Before you look for IROs, you need a clear picture of what the company does, where and with whom.
- Strategy and business model: products and services, markets, customers, key resources.
- Value chain map: main upstream suppliers and raw materials, own operations and sites, downstream use and end-of-life.
- Existing information: financial statements, the enterprise risk register, due diligence and supply chain audits, environmental permits, HR data, customer and investor questions.
- External sources: sector studies, peer reports, country and commodity risk data.
The revised ESRS 1 makes this step more proportionate. The DMA is based on reasonable and supportable information that is available without undue cost or effort (§32), and the value chain may be assessed without direct input from value chain actors, using average regional data, sector data or generally available information (§33). You do not need to survey every supplier. Our DMA document checklist lists the internal documents worth collecting first.
Step 3: Identify and engage stakeholders
Stakeholders fall into two groups: affected stakeholders whose interests are or could be affected by your activities (employees, value chain workers, communities, consumers, and nature as a "silent" stakeholder), and users of the sustainability statement such as investors, lenders and business partners.
Engagement with affected stakeholders remains "a key input" to the DMA (§42). The revised ESRS clarify, however, that engagement carried out as part of your due diligence processes is sufficient. You do not need a separate engagement process for the DMA. Civil society organisations, NGOs and trade unions can act as proxies for affected stakeholders.
Proportionate ways to collect stakeholder input:
- Interviews or workshops with internal experts and the works council.
- Short, targeted questionnaires for selected external groups (see our materiality assessment questionnaire with sample questions).
- Existing channels: grievance mechanisms, customer surveys, supplier audits, investor dialogues.
ESRS 2 IRO-1 only asks you to describe stakeholder consultation if you consulted. Our article on stakeholder analysis in double materiality shows how to map and prioritise stakeholder groups.
Step 4: Identify impacts, risks and opportunities
Now you turn context and stakeholder input into a list of IROs. For each one, record:
- Type: actual or potential impact (negative or positive), risk or opportunity.
- Value chain stage: upstream, own operations or downstream.
- Time horizon: short, medium or long term.
- Topic: the ESRS topic and sub-topic it belongs to.
Write IROs as specific statements ("GHG emissions from purchased steel", not "climate"). Specific IROs are easier to score and much easier to defend.
Top-down or bottom-up? The revised ESRS 1 allows both, and you can combine them topic by topic:
| Top-down (§27) | Bottom-up (§28) | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Conclude at topic or sub-topic level, based on strategy, business model, sectors, geographies and value chain | Identify and assess individual IROs |
| When to use it | The outcome is evident (e.g., climate is clearly material for a steel producer, biodiversity clearly not material for a software company) | The outcome is not evident or borderline |
| Documentation | A reasoned conclusion per topic | IRO list with scores |
The topic list is a starting point, not a checklist. The list of sustainability matters in Appendix A of ESRS 1 is non-binding guidance and "one of the inputs" to the DMA. It no longer contains sub-sub-topics; E3 is now simply "Water", and marine resources moved to E5. Our overview of the ESRS topics list 2026 shows the structure.
No exhaustive search. You are "not required to assess every possible impact, risk or opportunity" (§32), only the areas where material IROs are likely to arise. What you do need is a defensible rationale for where you looked and where you did not. A focused list of well-described IROs is more convincing than a long list of three hundred.
Step 5: Assess impact materiality
Impacts are assessed on severity and, for potential impacts, likelihood:
| Criterion | Question | Applies to |
|---|---|---|
| Scale | How grave is the impact (or how beneficial, for positive impacts)? | All impacts |
| Scope | How widespread is it: how many people, how large an area? | All impacts |
| Irremediable character | How hard is it to reverse or remedy? | Negative impacts |
| Likelihood | How probable is it that the impact occurs? | Potential impacts |

Three rules from the revised ESRS 1 deserve special attention:
- Human rights: for potential negative human rights impacts, severity takes precedence over likelihood (§40). A low probability does not make a severe human rights impact immaterial.
- Gross vs. net (§43): actual negative impacts are assessed as they actually manifested. Potential negative impacts may only be reduced by prevention and mitigation actions that are already implemented and can reasonably be expected to be effective. Planned measures do not count.
- Positive impacts (§44): assess them on their own, without netting them against negative impacts. Remediating your own negative impacts and simply complying with the law are not positive impacts.
The ESRS do not prescribe scales. Most companies use 1 to 5 scales with written definitions for each level. Our worked DMA example shows a complete scoring model, including how severity and likelihood are combined.
Score IROs without spreadsheet chaos
Materiality Master guides you through stakeholders, IROs, impact and financial scoring, thresholds and the materiality matrix, using the revised ESRS topic structure. Every judgement is documented for your auditor.
Step 6: Assess financial materiality and set thresholds
Financial materiality is based on the likelihood and potential magnitude of financial effects (§50) over the short, medium and long term: effects on cash flows, financial position, performance, cost of capital or access to finance. Many risks and opportunities follow directly from your impacts or from dependencies on natural and social resources, such as water availability or skilled labour.
Practical tips:
- Reuse your risk management scales. Calibrating magnitude to the same euro bands as your enterprise risk management connects the DMA to existing governance and makes it easier to defend.
- Think in time horizons. A risk that is small today (e.g., carbon pricing on imported materials) can be material in the medium term.
- Opportunities count too. New products, efficiency gains or better access to green finance are assessed in the same way.
Setting thresholds. The ESRS do not prescribe thresholds; you set your own and justify them. A common rule is that a topic is material if at least one IRO exceeds the impact threshold or the financial threshold. Discuss borderline results in a calibration workshop and document the reasoning. Our help article on adjusting thresholds in a materiality assessment shows how to configure and document them in Materiality Master.
Step 7: Consolidate, validate, document and map to datapoints
The final step turns scores into a decision that holds up in the audit and drives the report.
- Consolidate: aggregate IROs to the topic and sub-topic level and record for each topic whether it is material from the impact perspective, the financial perspective, both or neither. Top-down conclusions belong in the same list, with their rationale.
- Validate: check the result against the risk register, due diligence findings and management's view of the business. Have the result approved by the management board and, where relevant, the supervisory board or audit committee.
- Visualise (optional): a materiality matrix is not required by the ESRS, but it helps communicate the result. See the materiality matrix under the revised ESRS.
- Document for disclosure: prepare the IRO-1 description of your process, the IRO-2 description of material IROs and the SBM-3 link to strategy and business model. Record the date of the assessment, because IRO-1 asks when it was last updated.
- Map to datapoints: material topics determine which disclosure requirements and datapoints you report. EFRAG's 2026 draft list contains 359 datapoints, compared with 1,144 in the 2024 list. Our guide on how to identify your ESRS datapoints explains the logic, and the ESRS Datapoints Mapping Tool creates the list for your material topics automatically.
- Prepare for assurance: auditors check whether the process is complete, consistent and documented. Our DMA audit checklist lists what they typically ask for.
Keep it current. At each reporting date, consider whether significant changes have occurred in your business, value chain or methodology, and update the DMA only if they have (§34). Typical triggers are acquisitions or disposals, new sites, new product lines or a change of key suppliers. No change means a documented review, not a new assessment. In Materiality Master, you can duplicate last year's assessment as the starting point and transfer a DMA built under the 2023 ESRS into the revised topic structure; our guide to updating your double materiality assessment explains the annual review.
Inputs and outputs per step
| Step | Key inputs | Output |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Project and governance | Scope decision, ESRS version for FY2026, budget | Project plan, team and responsibilities, approved methodology and thresholds |
| 2. Context and value chain | Strategy, financial statements, risk register, sector and regional data | Business and value chain profile |
| 3. Stakeholders | Stakeholder map, due diligence engagement, questionnaires, interviews | Documented stakeholder input |
| 4. IRO identification | Context profile, stakeholder input, ESRS 1 Appendix A | IRO list per topic, top-down conclusions with rationale |
| 5. Impact materiality | IRO list, scoring scales, evidence on implemented measures | Impact scores per IRO |
| 6. Financial materiality | IRO list, risk management scales, financial data | Financial scores per IRO, threshold application |
| 7. Consolidation and documentation | All scores and conclusions, management review | Material topics, IRO-1/IRO-2/SBM-3 drafts, optional matrix, datapoint list, audit file |
Common mistakes in double materiality assessments
- Scoring topics instead of IROs. "Climate change: high" cannot be audited. Specific IROs can.
- Ignoring the value chain. The most severe impacts of many manufacturers sit upstream, not in their own plants.
- Setting thresholds after scoring. Approve the methodology first; otherwise the result looks engineered.
- Netting with planned measures. Under §43, only implemented and effective measures reduce potential impacts.
- Netting positive against negative impacts. §44 requires positive impacts to be assessed on their own.
- Building a three-hundred-item long list. The revised ESRS do not require an exhaustive search (§32). Focus beats completeness.
- Running a separate stakeholder survey for its own sake. Engagement from due diligence is sufficient (§42); collect targeted input where it adds information.
- No paper trail. Undocumented top-down conclusions and threshold choices are hard to defend in the assurance review.
How long does a double materiality assessment take, and what does it cost?
Time: for a mid-sized company with a structured tool, six to ten weeks from kick-off to management approval is realistic. Spreadsheet-based projects often take three to six months, because versions, comments and evidence end up scattered across files. Large groups with several entities need more time for alignment and validation. Follow-up years are much faster, since §34 only requires an update when something significant changes.
Cost: the main cost drivers are internal time, external support and tooling. Our customers report Big 4 quotes of roughly €50,000 to €200,000 for a full DMA. Software brings the external cost down substantially: Materiality Master costs €2,499 per year for unlimited assessments and users, and our Materiality Assessment-as-a-Service, in which our experts run the complete DMA for you, starts at €6,999. See DMA software vs. consultants for a full comparison and the pricing page for all plans.
Run your DMA in Materiality Master
Materiality Master follows the seven steps above and uses the revised ESRS 2026 topic structure. You can:
- add and rate stakeholders by interest, influence and knowledge to build your stakeholder matrix, link them to individual IROs and invite key stakeholders as users with restricted rights to rate specific IROs (unlimited users),
- identify IROs per topic, with support from the AI assistant or the AI agent that runs your double materiality assessment in a chat, and combine top-down conclusions with detailed scoring,
- score impact and financial materiality on your own scales, apply thresholds and generate the materiality matrix,
- attach evidence and comments to every judgement and rely on the audit trail to show when and why anything changed,
- generate a draft of your ESRS 2 IRO-1 disclosure from the assessment data,
- turn your material topics into the revised ESRS datapoints with the Datapoints Mapping Tool (Excel and PDF output).
Start your free trial to explore the core features, or compare plans on our pricing page. Consultancies running assessments for several clients can find out more on our page for consultants. Want to check which datapoints a topic triggers before you start? Browse them for free in the ESRS Datapoint Explorer 2026.
Key takeaways
- Double materiality means reporting on what matters from an impact perspective, a financial perspective or both. The DMA is the process that decides this.
- After Omnibus I, the DMA is mandatory for companies with more than 1,000 employees and more than €450 million net turnover; the revised ESRS apply from FY2027.
- The binding rules sit in ESRS 1 (method) and ESRS 2 IRO-1, IRO-2 and SBM-3 (disclosures). Scales, thresholds and the matrix are up to you.
- Follow seven steps: governance, context, stakeholders, IROs, impact materiality, financial materiality and thresholds, then consolidation, documentation and datapoint mapping.
- The revised ESRS make the process more proportionate (top-down conclusions, no exhaustive search, sector data, updates only on significant change) and stricter on gross vs. net and positive impacts.


